The tote bag problem: reusable only counts if it gets reused

By Pascal Vida

Picture a hotel room on the last morning of a three-day conference. The bed’s a mess, the kettle’s still warm, and next to it sits a small pile of branded freebies that didn’t make the cut for the carry-on. A lanyard. A stress ball. A flimsy plastic bottle. Probably a tote bag too, still folded.

I know that pile well, because my company puts logos on things for a living. More than 4,700 Australian brands have ordered merch through us, and the most useful thing we’ve learned is slightly awkward for a merch supplier to admit: the greenest branded product is often the one that never gets printed.

The suitcase test

Before we recommend anything for an event, we ask one question. Would someone pack it to take home?

Lanyards, paper showbags, novelty toys and lightweight plastic bottles usually fail. They don’t break. They just run out of jobs the moment the event ends. Things that solve an everyday problem, like a sturdy drink bottle, a cable pouch or a bag strong enough for the weekly shop, tend to make it home and keep working.

You can see the difference on the day. At one expo in Sydney, an exhibitor handed out 400 matte black drink bottles before 10am, and by mid-morning half the coffee queue was carrying one. Nobody carries a stress ball to the coffee queue.

The 131-use rule

In 2011 the UK Environment Agency published a life-cycle assessment of supermarket carrier bags. It found a cotton bag has to be used around 131 times before its global warming impact falls below that of a conventional single-use plastic bag used once. Cotton is resource-hungry to grow, so the bag starts life in carbon debt and pays it off one shop at a time.

Every Australian state and territory has now banned lightweight single-use plastic bags, which is good news. It has also produced an awful lot of “reusable” bags that get used twice. A cotton tote sitting in a cupboard isn’t greener than the plastic bag it replaced. It’s worse.

Reusable is a promise, not a material. It only comes true when someone actually reuses the thing.

Fewer, better

The most effective change a business or event organiser can make is also the least exciting one. Order fewer items, and order them for the people who will use them rather than for the headcount.

Durability is a big part of that. One client unpacking 300 custom stainless steel drink bottles for delegate packs at a Parramatta venue ran her thumbnail hard across the first logo. Nothing moved, because it was laser engraved into the steel. Those bottles will be in people’s bags long after the event lanyards are gone.

The same budget spent on half the quantity of something that passes the suitcase test does more for the brand and sends less of it to landfill.

Ask harder questions about materials

When it comes to eco-friendly promotional products, recycled PET, bamboo, cork and organic cotton all have their place. But “eco” on a product listing proves nothing on its own. Before ordering, ask your supplier:

  • What exactly is it made from, and what percentage is recycled content?

  • Is there a certification behind the claim, such as the Global Recycled Standard (GRS) for recycled content or FSC for timber and paper?

  • How long will it last in real use? A recycled bag that tears on its third shop hasn’t saved anything.

  • What happens to it at end of life in Australia? Can it be recycled here, or does it only sound like it can?

A good supplier answers those without flinching. If the answers get vague, your enthusiasm should too.

The box in the corner

There’s almost always a box left over after an event. Sixty caps. A carton of bottles. A stack of notebooks. A few habits stop it becoming waste:

  • Leave dates and event years off anything that could be used again. “Annual Conference” outlives “Conference 2026” by years.

  • Keep a merch cupboard, and check it before the next order goes in.

  • Pass useful extras on to staff, volunteers, a local school, a sports club or an op shop, where a good bottle or bag gets used instead of stored.

  • For long campaigns, order in stages rather than guessing the full quantity up front.

None of this needs a new product or a bigger budget. It needs one honest question before the order is placed: will anyone still be using this in a year?

If the answer is no, don’t print it. A logo nobody uses isn’t marketing. It’s landfill with nicer typography.

About Pascal Vida

Pascal Vida is the Founder and CEO of Promo Punks, an Australian supplier of custom branded merchandise. He would rather sell you 200 bottles people keep than 2,000 they leave next to a hotel kettle.

INDEPENDENT NEWS IS IMPORTANT.

Enjoy reading Eco Voice? Please help us by purchasing a GIFT Voucher or send one to a friend and encourage people to purchase trees or seeds via The Native Shop – www.nativeshop.com.au

Plants, seeds & more delivered to your door!

Share it :

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *